Free enterprise and the rule of law took a hit today as WalMart caved to public outcry generated by the anti-business trial bar and the usual socialist suspects. Actually, the trial bar does like business as long as it's them doing it by producing nothing through publicly funded courts.
Typical of this attitude is John Cummings, a Texas personal injury lawyer who was "seething" in December that WalMart would have the gall to enforce its contractual rights in court. Mr. Cummings apparently believes that some are more equal than others under the law. One wonders how much he and other WalMart critics donated to the Shank family.
I dont know Mr. Cummings and I'm sure he thinks he means well, but the notion that success and productivity is prima facie evidence of evil intent unless you bow to the extortionist left is an assault on basic fairness and common sense. In short, it's Un-American.
The crux of this case was Subrogation. Something that Cummings and others believe "screw the little guy" No, it's a concept that prevents double dipping in insurance claims and protects all of us. That's exactly what happened here. WalMart paid Mrs. Shank over $400,000 for medical expenses which were reimbursed to her by a third party. WalMart then wanted their money back. Not too hard to figure out, is it? This is the kind of thing Judge Judy disposes of in about fifteen minutes in $500 auto accident cases with no complaints because it's fair and equitable. But because WalMart is a big bad corporation that has committed crimes like employing 1.3 million people and offering low priced products to average Americans, then fairness be damned.
The fact that Mrs. Shank contractually agreed to this and that the courts sided with WalMart matters not to left wing demagogues and if you bring it up, then you're obviously a heartless bastard.
One of the more nonsensical arguments I've heard is that WalMart should pay because if they don't, then taxpayers would have to through Medicaid. First of all, since when is it incumbent on a private concern to mitigate the losses of the federal government? And where do people think this money is coming from? The employees, customers and most important, the shareholders of WalMart. Most of those shares are owned by individuals, pension and mutual funds which are owned by...you guessed it. You and me.
No comments:
Post a Comment